CAS ad hoc Division (O.G. Sydney) 00/010 Alan Tsagaev / International Weightlifting Federation (IWF)
Weightlifting
Exclusion of a National Weightlifting Federation due to three positive doping cases
Lack of legal basis for such sanction
Although an international federation may have certain general discretionary powers to govern its sport even in the absence of specific provisions in the statutes or regulations, a suspension of an entire federation from participation in the Olympic Games, including innocent athletes who have not committed a doping offence or any other violation of the applicable rules, at least requires an explicit, and unambiguous legal basis.
Mr. Alan Tzagaev is a Bulgarian Athlete selected to compete in the weightlifiting events at the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games.
On 22 September 2000 the Executiver Board of the International Weightlifting Federation (IWF) rendered the following decision against the Bulgarian Weightlifting Federation after 3 Bulgarian weightlifters tested positive at the Sydney Olympic Games:
1.) The Bulgarian Weightlifting Federation is suspended forthwith for a period of not less than 12 months, pending further investigation.
2.) The Bulgarian Weightlifting Federation must present a detailed project – supported by their National Olympic Committee and National Sports Authorities – ensuring the elimination of the use of doping among their athletes.
3.) All remaining lifters as well as officials from Bulgaria will not be allowed to take part in the Olympic Games.
Hereafter on 22 september 2000 the Bulgarian Athlete Alan Tsagaev appealed this IWF decision of 22 September 2000 with the CAS ad hoc Division at the Sydney Olympic Games and requested the Panel to set aside his exclusion to compete at the Olympic Games.
The Athlete argued that under the IWF Rules after three positive doping tests within one year, the IWF must impose a $ 50.000 fine on the respective member federation. A suspension may be imposed only in the event of non payment of that fine and the IWF made no request for payment of a fine to the Bulgarian sports organisations.
The Panel rules that the IWF decision of 22 September 2000 lacked a sufficient legal foundation and must therefore be annulled in its relevant portions as far as the Athlete is affected, i.e. by reference to items 1 and 3 thereof.
Therefore the CAS ad hoc Division decides on 25 September 2000:
The application is granted insofar as points 1 and 3 of the decision made by the International Weightlifting Federation Executive Board on 22 September 2000 are annulled for lack of legal basis, with the consequence that the Applicant is allowed to participate in these Olympic Games.